Best Historic Stays: The Florida House Inn on Amelia Island
Discover one of Florida's most iconic and historic stays: The Florida House Inn in Fernandina Beach. With a storied past spanning more than a 160 years, this charming inn on Amelia Island has hosted a wide array of guests, from presidents to revolutionaries and the nation’s elite families. Now, it's your turn to experience it!
A Legacy of Hospitality
The Florida House Inn was established in 1857 as a boarding house for railroad workers building the line between Amelia Island and Cedar Key.
Then, during the Civil War, the building housed Union soldiers. In 1873, Annie Leddy purchased the property, breaking societal norms by owning and managing the business. Under her leadership, the Inn blossomed and welcomed high-profile guests like President Ulysses S. Grant, Cuban revolutionary José Martí, and Lucy Carnegie, who often sailed over from Cumberland Island with her wealthy friends.
After Annie’s passing in 1908, the Inn was run by her daughter until it changed ownership and transitioned into a boarding house in the 1940s. Decades of neglect took their their toll and, by 1990, the building was nearly condemned. Thankfully, passionate owners restored it. Today, it’s under the stewardship of the Saltmarsh family.
A Timeless Experience Today
The history and charm are unmistakable as soon as you see the vibrant green and red exterior of the Inn and its welcoming verandas with plenty of seating. Inside, you’ll find historic heart-of-pine floors, vintage photos and paintings, and antiques—like Annie Leddy’s shoes by the fireplace. The thoughtful touches help guests connect with the Inn’s storied past.
The Inn offers 17 distinct rooms, including a bridal suite, cozy Railroad Twin rooms ideal for traveling friends, and a variety of Queen and King accommodations. Guests can even book Room #1, where Martí is said to have stayed. You’ll find a painting of him above a desk.
I stayed in a Deluxe King room, one of the newest additions to the Inn. My room featured a decorative fireplace, TV, mini-fridge, and a large tub.
One of the most striking features of the Inn is the massive 280-year-old oak tree that feels like part of the building itself, with its sprawling branches making a statement on both floors. To reach my room, I walked beneath one of its huge branches and was captivated by its majesty. The perspective is enchanting, especially when the resurrection fern is in bloom.
During your stay, also take time to appreciate the beautiful gardens, bird feeders, many seating areas, and the inn’s kitties!
“It’s not your cookie-cutter hotel that anyone could stay in. There’s a story here. There’s charm,” said Innkeeper Emily Saltmarsh.
Dining at the Florida House Inn can be just as memorable as the stay itself. Guests wake up to a daily continental breakfast featuring homemade quiche, bagels, yogurt, and juice.
On-site dining and drinking options add to the historic experience, with highlights including The Mermaid Bar, which was originally a gathering spot for railroad workers and Union soldiers. The whimsical mermaid theme, dating back to the early 1900s, is sprinkled throughout the property with playful statues and décor.
Leddy’s Porch, named in honor of Annie Leddy, is open weekends from 9 am to 2:30 pm, serving Southern-style favorites like buttermilk fried chicken. It’s also beloved for Bottomless Bloody Marys and Mimosas, making it a must-visit for brunch fans.
Exploring Amelia Island
The Florida House Inn’s prime location places guests steps away from Amelia Island’s best attractions. After appreciating the Inn’s history, venture out to explore these spots:
Green Turtle Tavern: Right next door, this lively spot offers a beachy vibe and live music.
Amelia Island River Cruises: Embark on a narrated tour highlighting the history and wildlife of Amelia and Cumberland Islands. Keep an eye out for wild horses on Cumberland Island!
Amelia Island Coffee: A cozy spot for a caffeine fix. Don’t miss the Beach Babe Iced Latte, a refreshing blend of coconut and sea salt.
Amelia Island Museum of History: Housed in a former jail, this museum offers fascinating insights into local history, including the preservation of American Beach’s famous Nana Sand Dune.
Palace Saloon: Florida’s oldest continuously operating bar, established in 1907, offering live music and historic ambiance.
